Showing posts with label mearsheimer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mearsheimer. Show all posts

20091013

Norman Podhoretz, editor of Comentary Magazine, debunks conspiracy allegations of Jewish dual-loyalism in government

Reformed-liberal, branded "neo-Conservative" political advisor, Norman Podhoretz, debunks notions of an organized Jewish conspiracy having influenced U.S. foreign policy towards Israel's, but not America's, primary interests.



Learning from France's Dreyfus Affaire of the late 19th-century, allegations of Jewish dual-loyalism were revealed to be a scapegoating distraction from the acutal perfidy of others' treasonous activities within the government.


Filmed at the Skirball Center through the efforts of Children of Jewish Holocaust Survivors of L.A.

20070926

To Defeat the Juggernaut of Imperialist Islamofascism, Should Washington Embrace Petro-Islamists Dismantling the Land of the God of Israel?

Would weakening American support for Israel end the global Jihad?

In the Jerusalem Post, CEO of private intelligence supplier, Stratfor, Dr. George Friedman, takes on the myths by Profs. Mearsheimer and Walt about ending Jihad by weakening America's support for Israel.

"Do Israeli interests diverge from US interests to the extent that the Israel lobby is taking US foreign policy in directions it wouldn't go otherwise, in directions that counter the US national interest? ...

It wasn't the (British vs German) lobbying interest (for the U.S. involvement on their side in WWII), massive though it was, but geopolitical necessity that drove US intervention.

Has the Israel lobby caused the United States to act in ways that contravene US interests? For example, by getting the United States to support Israel, did it turn the Arab world against the Americans? Did it support Israeli repression of Palestinians, and thereby generate an Islamist radicalism that led to 9/11? Did it manipulate US policy on Iraq so that the United States invaded Iraq on behalf of Israel? These allegations have all been made. If true, they are very serious charges. ...

Now we get to the heart of the matter. If the United States broke ties with Israel, would the US geopolitical position be improved? In other words, if it broke with Israel, would Iran or al Qaida come to view the United States in a different way? Critics of the Israel lobby argue that, except for US support for Israel, the United States would have better relations in the Muslim world, and would not be targeted by al Qaida or threatened by Iran. In other words, except for the Israel lobby's influence, the United States would be much more secure.

Al Qaida does not see Israel by itself as its central problem. Its goal is the resurrection of the caliphate -- and it sees US support for Muslim regimes as the central problem. If the United States abandoned Israel, al Qaida would still confront US support for countries such as Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan. For al Qaida, Israel is an important issue, but for the United States to soothe al Qaeda, it would have to abandon not only Israel, but its non-Islamist allies in the Middle East.

Map of Islamist supremacist conflicts throughout the world (click to enlarge):


It has been said that the Israelis inspired the US invasion of Iraq. There is no doubt that Israel was pleased when, after 9/11, the United States saw itself as an anti-Islamist power. Let us remind our more creative readers, however, that benefiting from something does not mean you caused it. ...

Portraying the Israel lobby as super-powerful behooves two groups: Critics of US Middle Eastern policy and the Israel lobby itself. Critics get to say the US relationship with Israel is the result of manipulation and corruption. Thus, they get to avoid discussing the actual history of Israel, the United States and the Middle East. The lobby benefits from having robust power because one of its jobs is to raise funds -- and the image of a "killer" lobby opens a lot more pocketbooks than does the idea that both Israel and the United States are simply pursuing their geopolitical interests and that things would go on pretty much the same even without slick lobbying.

The great irony is that the critics of US policy and the Israel lobby both want to believe in the same myth -- that great powers can be manipulated to harm themselves by crafty politicians.

The British didn't get the United States into the world wars, and the Israelis aren't maneuvering the Americans into being pro-Israel.

Beyond its ability to exert itself on small things, the Israel lobby is powerful in influencing Washington to do what it is going to do anyway. What happens next in Iraq is not up to the Israel lobby -- though it and the Saudi Embassy have a different story.

20070918

"The Israel Lobby" - Not Anti-Semitic?


Authors John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt spoke at the Hammer Museum in Los Angeles on 18 September in promotion of their book, "The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy," in which they allege that American-Jewish interests influence American foreign policy detrimentally.

What I perceived there was an anti-Israel audience embracing academic legitimizing of their enmity and resentment. But what underlies the particular enmity towards the 'Israel lobby' rather than, say, the Oil lobby, in attempting to guide Washington into policies detrimental to American interests?


The Forward reports that in an indication of the strong interest the book is attracting in Europe, it is being translated into German, Dutch, Danish, French, Italian, Spanish and even Catalan. It is being translated into Arabic and will be published across the Arab world and in Indonesia, the most populous Muslim country in the world.

In the essay DEFINING ANTI-SEMITISM author Prof. Jeffery Herf explains the anti-semitic foundations of "The Israel Lobby."


"Jeffrey Goldberg's review of Walt and Mearsheimer's The Israel Lobby is superb. Hopefully it will receive wide attention. I would add this historical note regarding the nature of anti-Semitism.

Goldberg writes: "But since many people in the West are queasy about attaching the label of anti-Semitism to almost anybody, regarding the charge of anti-Semitism as itself proof of prejudice, let me begin by describing bin Laden's view of history less inflammatorily--not as anti-Semitic, but as Judeocentric. He believes that Jews exercise disproportionate control over world affairs, and that world affairs may therefore be explained by reference to the Jews. A Judeocentric view of history is one that regards the Jews as the center of the story, and therefore the key to it. Judeocentrism is a single- cause theory of history, and as such it is, almost by definition, a conspiracy theory. Moreover, Judeocentrism comes in positive forms and negative forms. The positive form of Judeocentrism is philo-Semitism, the negative form is anti-Semitism."

In my book, The Jewish Enemy: Nazi Propaganda During World War II and the Holocaust I argued that the distinctive and defining feature of Nazism's radical anti-Semitism was precisely the idea that Jews were at the center of mid-20th century history, that they had started World War II, made possible the alliance between the Soviet Union and the Western democracies, and conducted the war as one of extermination aimed at the German people. That is, what Goldberg calls a negative form of "Judeocentrism" was the core of the radical anti-Semitism that accompanied and justified the mass murder of the Jews of Europe. Radical anti-Semitism was a conspiracy theory that first and foremost defined the Jews as a political actor. To be sure, racial biology played a role in the Nazi worldview, but the most dangerous aspect of Nazi anti-Semitism concerned what the Jews were alleged to have done, not what they looked like.

Goldberg is quite right that many people in the West are reluctant to attach the label of anti-Semitism to arguments. Yet this may also be due to a deficiency of historical knowledge about what radical anti-Semitism amounted to in the 20th century. The attribution to Jews of enormous power used for evil purposes, what Goldberg plausibly calls Judeocentrism stood--and stands--at the center of anti-Semitic arguments.

Goldberg is right to draw attention to the depressing decision of Farrar, Strauss and Giroux to publish the Walt/Mearsheimer book. Perhaps Goldberg's ironic suggestion that publishing the work will undermine such arguments is the case. But the book is there with the imprimatur of a prestigious press. The publication of this book should contribute to a diminution of that prestige. Perhaps the editors at one of our previously finest publishers are simply ignorant of the history and nature of anti-Semitism. Whatever the case may be, Goldberg's review deserves a wide reading and discussion. --Jeffrey Herf

20070910

Uncanny fates await mercenary opponents of Israel

This sixth 9/11 anniversary a day prior to the 'week of judgment and atonement' on the Hebrew calendar, reminds us of the ramifications of prominent western leaders selling-out their integrity to the Arab enemies of Israel.

The Mohammed al-Dura fauxtography case is being exposed as a conspiracy by France2 TV against truth (and Israel).

Arab-donation recipients, Former Pres. Jimmy Carter and Professors Mearsheimer & Walt have both come out with distorting, defamatory best-selling books against Israel and its Jewish supporters.

Washington Post journalist, Glenn Kessler's book reveals U.S. Secy of State Condoleeza Rice's having intimidated Israel's Ariel Sharon Administration to unilaterally surrender Jewish presence in Gaza - in an attempt to 'promote peace' by appeasing the Arab world. Lessons to be considered in planning November's 'Peace Conference.'

This pop song, "There's a Judgment and There's a Judge" by Ariel Zilber points-out the uncanny fates which have befallen Israel's leaders who surrendered Jewish Gaza to Israel's enemies as an example of the metaphysical ramifications of acting against the G-d of Israel's essence in this world.

"There's a judgment and there's a judge, and the account will come;
The one who banished without mercy, in Gaza and in Samaria.
They were there in order to provide security to us all
And now, they are wandering around, wounded, without a place to dwell.

There's a judgment and there's a judge, they will carry the responsibility.
One is a judge, and a general, one is a simple soldier.
There's a payment for the flattery, for the stupidity, for the arrogance.
There's a judgment and there's a judge and there's no mistake in here.

There's a judgment and there's a judge, my brother, but there's no despair.
In Amona all the youngsters of the bloc were gathered
They didn't think at all about escaping from the very one derogatory soldier
And I internalized that there's a chance that the youth is decisive.

There's a judgment and there's a judge, ask anyone in the street
Where's the father, where's the son, think about it, think
And sages have already told and it was also written in the books
The pitied one will only be the one who left the sin.


There's a judgment and there's a judge, listen soldier, policeman
And all the ones who gives the land of the nation to the enemy
All of the land of Israel isn't mine nor yours
The one who buy land and sky is beautify himself in it (not clear).

There's a judgment and there's a judge and there's the one who warned
The same prophet who shines for us for years already
And declared that he will fight, will collect the price by himself
From the one who will talk with them (enemies) even about one grain (of the country).

There's a judgment and there's a judge and there are terrific examples
Arik, Omri, Tzachi, Basi, Katzav and Chaluts
There are more in the list, to those who will come next they still have a choice
If they will stop from making fun of the land of Israel.

There's a judgment and there's a judge, 2 years for the banish
The son has been convicted, and also the father already isn't worth a penny
There's one who doesn't forget and he doesn't forgive on that
The one who destroyed such a flourishing region won't escape."

(Conversely, donations to support DemoCast.Org's mission will merit multiplied blessings)!