![]() |
| Loay Alnaji, carrying the bullhorn he used to hit Mr. Paul Kessler, accompanied here by Nashat Mshaiel from the Islamic Society of Simi Valley. |
Write to the Presiding Judge Before June 24 – Demand Review of the Private Meetings and Lenient Deal
This is a landmark case. When Hamas invaded and massacred Israelis on October 7, 2023, the United States saw more than 12,000 anti-Israel protests in the following months. On November 5, 2023 — just 29 days later — Loay Alnaji, who had come from the Islamic Society of Simi Valley with other members, struck and killed 69-year-old Paul Kessler for the simple act of holding an Israeli flag at a “Justice for Palestine” protest in Thousand Oaks.
Paul Kessler became the first Jewish-American killed at a pro-Palestine rally in the United States after October 7. Mr. Kessler, a Jewish-American counter-protester, was the first non-Muslim killed by a Muslim at a political protest in America.
Just 29 days after the October 7 massacre, the Islamic Society of Simi Valley deliberately traveled to the more Jewish community of Thousand Oaks. During the protest, Loay Alnaji struck Paul Kessler in the face with a bullhorn. The coroner documented welt marks on Kessler’s face consistent with the blow. Mr. Kessler fell, suffered fatal head trauma, and died the next day.
| Paul Kessler stood up for the Israeli victims massacred by Hamas 4-weeks after Oct. 7, '23 before being struck to his death by Loay Alnaji |
Hal Eisner, KTTV News (2023): “Paul Kessler was murdered for the simple act of carrying an Israeli flag.” A student at the scene also reported hearing: “we need to kill you all… you’re not belonging here.”
Jump to 0:09 – Stop at 0:55
On May 5, 2026, Alnaji entered a guilty plea to involuntary manslaughter. According to his attorney Ron Bamieh, Judge Derek Malan offered the plea deal — up to 365 days in county jail plus 3 years formal probation — after several private meetings with the defense attorney alone. Bamieh told reporters that Judge Malan had characterized the killing as nothing more than “two old guys had a dispute and an accident happened.”
Private meetings between a judge and only one side in a criminal case are highly unusual and generally considered inappropriate. California judicial ethics rules strongly discourage ex parte communications — discussions about a pending case with only one party (here, only the defense) while excluding the prosecutor and the victim’s family. Such meetings can create the appearance of favoritism or bias, especially when the judge and defense attorney previously worked together in the same District Attorney’s Office. In this case, the DA’s office and Kessler’s family strongly objected to the lenient offer, yet their input appears to have been bypassed.
This approach bypassed normal protocol in which plea negotiations are conducted by the District Attorney with input from the victim’s family. The Ventura County DA’s office and Paul Kessler’s family strongly objected, yet their position was overruled. Sentencing is scheduled for June 25, 2026.
Even if Judge Malan imposes the full 365 days in county jail, Alnaji is expected to serve very little actual time. He has been out on bail since shortly after his November 2023 arrest and has spent almost no time in custody. In addition, judges in Ventura County routinely reduce actual jail time significantly through credits, good behavior, work release, or other considerations. It is entirely possible that Alnaji could serve only a few days or weeks — or potentially be released on the day of sentencing.
This is the predictable outcome of a system that has repeatedly refused to treat antisemitic violence with the seriousness it deserves.
Look at the clear pattern of antisemitic crimes inflicted on Jewish people in Los Angeles in recent years:
- UCLA Encampment (Spring 2024): Over 200 arrests, but the only two people actually prosecuted were Jewish pro-Israel counter-protesters.
- 2020 BLM attacks on Jewish stores (Beverly Blvd, Fairfax Blvd, Pico Blvd): Numerous Jewish-owned businesses were smashed, looted, and robbed, many with explicit antisemitic targeting. Virtually zero meaningful prosecutions or sentences.
- Adas Torah Synagogue riot (June 2024): Muslims rioted and battered Jews outside the synagogue. Zero reported prosecutions or sentences for the attackers.
Yet in Paul Kessler’s case — the first prominent killing of a Jewish-American by a Muslim anti-Israel demonstrator — it was not merely “an accident between two old guys.” The eyewitnesses tell a very different story.
Footage from the scene shows Mr. Kessler lying on the sidewalk bleeding after being struck, while other protesters continued their demonstration nearby.
Jump to 0:44 – Stop at 1:20
Rabbi Mark Blazer at the 1-year vigil (Nov 2024): “...on the anniversary of his murder we're calling on the DA in Ventura County... to make sure that those who perpetrated this act of hate, this act of violence are brought to Justice. It’s incumbent on our community to exercise Justice, to practice mercy and Justice, to help create peace, to help create shalom.”
Jump to 0:00 – Stop at 0:25
Jump to 0:25 • 1:12 (“cut the Jew into tiny pieces”) • 2:45 (Gaza betrayal) – Stop at 3:01
Never Again should be more than a slogan — it is an imperative. If we allow this targeted killing of a Jewish-American man holding an Israeli flag to be reduced to a mere “accident,” with the killer potentially serving only a tiny fraction of an already lenient sentence - while he continues to collect a paycheck, we betray the martyred Paul Kessler and send a clear message that Judeo-Christian lives are disposable.
The public can still push back against both the lenient outcome and the unusual handling of this case. It could be useful to send copies to both the DA’s Office and Probation. The more voices raised before June 24th, the better the chance for real justice.
Note: Ventura County does not provide public email addresses for case correspondence. Please use the official contact forms or mail physical letters so they become part of the official court record.
| Priority | Where to Send | Why It Matters Now | Contact Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best | Ventura County Probation Agency | They prepare the official Pre-Sentence Report that Judge Malan will read before deciding the sentence |
Phone: (805) 654-2106 → Online Contact Form |
| Very Good | Court Clerk – Hon. Derek Malan | Letters go into the official court file that the judge will see before sentencing |
Ventura County Superior Court 800 South Victoria Avenue Ventura, CA 93009 Re: People v. Loay Abdel Fattah Alnaji |
| Good | Presiding Judge of the Ventura County Superior Court | Can review how the case was assigned and the private meetings between Judge Malan and the defense attorney |
Ventura County Superior Court 800 South Victoria Avenue Ventura, CA 93009 Attn: Presiding Judge |
| Fair | Ventura County District Attorney’s Office | They can still submit a sentencing recommendation, though their influence is limited now that the plea has been accepted |
Phone: (805) 654-2500 → Online Contact Form |
Note: Fill in forms and send your letter in time to be delivered in Thousand Oaks, California by Wednesday, 24 June.
Sample Letter – Demand a Harsher Sentence
[Your Full Name] [Your Address] [City, State, ZIP] [Email] [Phone] [Date] Honorable Derek D. Malan Ventura County Superior Court 800 South Victoria Avenue Ventura, CA 93009 Re: People v. Loay Abdel Fattah Alnaji – Sentencing June 25, 2026 Dear Judge Malan, I am writing regarding the sentencing of Loay Alnaji in the killing of Paul Kessler. Paul Kessler was the first Jewish-American killed by a Muslim anti-Israel protester after the October 7, 2023 Hamas massacre. Mr. Alnaji has already received significant leniency through the plea agreement. I respectfully urge the Court to impose the maximum sentence allowed — the full 365 days in county jail plus the maximum period of probation. A light sentence in this case would send the wrong message and fail to deliver justice for Paul Kessler and his family. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, [Your Full Name]
Note: To contact Loay Alnaji's defense attorney Ron Bamieh is not recommended.
Sample Letter – Challenge the Judicial Process & Private Meetings
[Your Full Name] [Your Address] [City, State, ZIP] [Email] [Phone] [Date] Presiding Judge Ventura County Superior Court 800 South Victoria Avenue Ventura, CA 93009 Re: People v. Loay Abdel Fattah Alnaji – Request for Review of Judicial Assignment and Conduct Dear Presiding Judge, I am writing to express serious concern regarding the handling of the above case. Judge Derek Malan was assigned to this case after the death of the original judge. It has been reported that Judge Malan held multiple private meetings with defense attorney Ron Bamieh alone before offering a lenient plea deal, despite strong objections from the District Attorney’s office and the victim’s family. These circumstances raise legitimate questions about the appearance of impartiality and the appropriateness of the case assignment. I respectfully request that your office review: 1. How Judge Malan was assigned to this case, and 2. Whether the private meetings between the judge and only the defense attorney were consistent with judicial ethics and proper procedure. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Sincerely, [Your Full Name]
Important: Please ensure that you send these letters to arrive to their destination in Southern California by Wednesday 24 June.
